Engineering Geology

Engineering Geology

Evaluation of the unconfined compressive strength in solidification and stabilization of a phenol-contaminated soil using ordinary and organophilic clays

Authors
nima Headarzadeh
Tania Taslimi
10.18869/acadpub.jeg.11.4.343
Abstract
Introduction

One of the most important 1-ring aromatic organic pollutants is phenol and its related compounds. These compounds are classified as hazardous wastes base on U.S.EPA primary contaminates list. The phenolic compounds are very poisonous and these are harmful for human health and also for other biota.

To control the movement of such hazardous organic waste in a contaminated soil, solidification/stabilization (S/S) process can be an effective alternative. Due to the negative impact of organic compounds on the cement hydration, the cement-based S/S may be not effective for controlling the movement of such pollutants. To avoid these effects, using some additives during solidification period has been recommended. One of the proposed of such compounds is organophilic clay that is the modified montmorillonite by quaternary ammonium salts (QAS). There are several researches to evaluate the organophilic clay effect on adsorption and stabilization of organic compounds during S/S process. The effectivity of S/S process can be examined by several tests such as leaching test, durability, unconfined compressive strength (UCS), etc.

In this study, efficiency of ordinary and organophilic clay was evaluated in the solidification and stabilization process based on unconfined compressive strength of a phenol-contaminated soil.

Material and methods

In this study, an artificially phenol contaminated sand was considered to evaluate the effectivity of the white cement based S/S process by using two different additives of ordinary and organophilic clay.

The contaminated sand contains 2000 ppm of phenol. S/S process was conducted on 14 samples with different amounts of white cement (15 and 30 wt%) as binder and ordinary/organophilic clay (0, 8, 15, and 30 wt % for each of them) as the additives. Two zero percent additive samples are considered as control samples.

All samples were cured for 28 days and then UCS test was conducted for all of them.

Results and discussion

Unconfined compressive strength of all examined samples were ranged from 2226 to 6999 KPa. In the samples with equal amount of cement, th higher UCS values can be observed in blank samples (without any additives and phenol). By adding phenol in the examined sand, UCS of the solidified sample reduces 3 -3.5%.Moreover, results showed that UCS was reduced by increasing the amount of clays. The reduction of the samples containing organophilic clay was higher than samples containing ordinary clay. Unconfined compressive strength values of all samples met the minimum standards indicated by France, Netherlands, Britain and America for disposal in a sanitary landfill. The sample with 30% white cement and 8% bentonite was the maximum amount of UCS (4856 KPa) and the sample with 15% white cement and 30% organophilic clay was the minimum one (2226 KPa). In this study, the average cost of organophilic clay-based solidified samples was 2.3 to 2.8 times more than the average cost of the bentonite-based solidified samples.

Conclusion

In this study, the strength of the cement-based solidified samples contaminated by phenol was investigated. The summary of the findings of the research is as follows:

1. By adding the phenol to pure sand, the UCS of the samples can be reduced 3-3.5 %.

2. Addition of organophilic clay reduces the UCS of the samples more than the ordinary clay (bentonite) in the same amount.

3. All samples met the recommended UCS level for the S/S process. The minimum UCS level is for the sample with 15% of cement and 30% of organophilic clay.

The cost of S/S process is between 23 and 650 $/ton of contaminated soil depending on the amount of used additives and binder. The samples containing organophilic clay has a higher cost than the similar sample containing ordinary clay.

4. To evaluate the S/S process effectivity, a leaching test of phenol (such as TCLP) is recommended ./files/site1/files/0Extended_Abstract2.pdf
Keywords
solidification and stabilization
Unconfined compressive strength
Phenol
Organophilic clay
 1. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA), "Soil Guidance Values for Phenol Contamination", The Environment Agency (2005) 6-34. ## 2. Michalowicz J., Duda W., "Phenols-Sources and Toxicity", Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, Vol.16 (2007) 347-362. ## 3. Conner J. R., "Chemical Fixation and Solidification of Hazardous Wastes" 1st Edition (1990) 673-681. ## 4. Spence R. D., Shi C., "Stabilization and Solidification of Hazardous, Radioactive and Mixed Wastes", CRC Press (2004) 392. ## 5. U.S.EPA, "Solidification/Stabilization Resource Guide", Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response (1999a). ## 6. U.S.EPA, "Solidification/Stabilization Use at Superfund Sites", Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response (2000). ## 7. U.S.EPA, "Treatment Technologies for Site Cleanup: Annual Status Report", 12th edition (2007). 8. Lampris C., Stegemann J. A., Cheeseman C. R., "Solidification/Stabilisation of Air Pollution Control Residues using Portland cement: Physical Properties and Chloride Leaching", Waste Management, Vol.29 (2009) 1067-1075. ## 9. Malviya R., Chaudhary R., "Factors Affecting Hazardous Waste Solidification/Stabilization", Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol.137 (2006b) 267-276. ## 10. U.S.EPA, "Records of Decision Analysis of Superfund Sites Employing Solidification/Stabilization as Component of the Selected Remedy", Washington, DC (1994). ## 11. Tittlebaum M., Eaton H., Cartledge F., Walsh M., Roy A., "Procedures for Characterizing Effects of Organics on Solidification/Stabilization of Hazardous Wastes", Hazardous and Industrial Solid Waste Testing and Disposal, Vol.6 (1986) 308-318. ## 12. Vipulanandan C., Krishnan S., "Leachability and Biodegradation of High Concentration of Phenol and O-chlorophenol", Hazardous Waste & Hazardous Materials, Vol.10 (1993) 27-46. ## 13. Montgomery D. M., Sollars C. J., Perry R., "Optimization of Cement-based Stabilization/Solidification of Organic-containing Industrial Wastes using Organophilic Clays", Waste Management & Research, Vol.9 (1991) 21-34. ## 14. Cioffi R., Maffucci L., Santoro L., Glasser F. P., "Stabilization of Chloro-organics using Organophilic Bentonite in a Cement-blast Furnace Slag Matrix", Waste Management, Vol.21 (2001) 561-660. ## 15. Guray S., Vedat P., Nezih K. S., Gizem K., "Properties of Steel Foundry Electric Arc Furnace Dust Solidified/Stabilized with Portland Cement", Journal of Environmental Management, Vol.85 (2007) 190-197. ## 16. Voglar G. E., Lestan D., "Efficiency Modeling of Solidification/ Stabilization of Multi-metal Contaminated Industrial Soil using Cement and Additives" Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol.192 (2011) 753-762. ## 17. Montgomery D. M., Sollars C. J., Sheriff T. S., Perry R., "Organophilic clays for the Successful Stabilization/Solidification of Problematic Industrial Wastes", Environmental Technology Letters, Vol.9 (1988) 1403-1412. ## 18. Alther G. R., Evans J. C., Pancoski S. E., "Organically Modified Clays for Stabilization of Organic Hazardous Wastes", Conference Superfund 88, Washington DC (1988). ## 19. Hebatpuria V. M., Arafat H. A., Bishop P. L., Pinto N. G., "Leaching Behavior of Selected Aromatics in Cement-based Solidification/ Stabilization under Different Leaching Tests", Environmental Engineering Science, Vol.16 (1999) 451-463. ## 20. Shin H. S., Jun K. S., "Cement-based Stabilization/Solidification of Organic Contaminated Hazardous Wastes using Na-bentonite and Silica-fume", Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part A: Toxic/ Hazardous Substances and Environmental Engineering, Vol.30 (1995), 651-668. ## 21. Jun K. S., Shin H. S., "Microstructural Analysis of OPC/Silica-fume/Na-bentonite Interaction in Cement Based Solidification of Organic Contaminated Hazardous Waste", Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part A: Toxic/Hazardous Substances and Environmental Engineering, Vol.32 (1999) 913-928. ## 22. Cadena F., "Use of Tailored Bentonite for Selective Removal of Organic Pollutants", Journal of Environmental Engineering, Vol.115 (1989) 756-767. ## 23. حیدرزاده ن.، گیتی‌پور س.، "تثبیت و جامدسازی هیدروکربن‌های آروماتیک چند حلقه‌ای در خاک به‌وسیلۀ سیمان و خاک رس اصلاح شده"، پایان‌نامۀ کارشناسی ارشد، دانشکدۀ محیط زیست، دانشگاه تهران (1388). ## 24. Southern Clay Products Inc. (SCP), Clay Chemistry (2008b), http://www.rockwoodadditives.com/claytone/chemistry2.asp. Access date: October (2008). ## 25. Vipulanandan C., "Effect of Clays and Cement on the Solidification/ Stabilization of Phenol-Contaminated Soils", Waste Management, Vol.15 (1995) 399-406. ## 26. Lo I. M. C., "Solidification/Stabilization of Phenolic Waste using Organic-clay Complex", Journal of Environmental Engineering, Vol.122 (1996) 850-855. ## 27. محبی م.، گیتی‌پور س.، "بررسی بازدهی روش جامدسازی و تثبیت خاک‌های آلوده به هیدروکربن‌های نفتی به‌کمک سیمان پرتلند و رس اصلاح‌شده، مطالعۀ مورد خاک آلوده به آلاینده کرسول در پالایشگاه تهران" پایان‌نامهۀ کارشناسی ارشد، دانشکدۀ محیط زیست، دانشگاه تهران (1389). ## 28. Environment Agency, "Contaminants in Soil: Collation of Toxicological Data and Intake Values for Humans", R&D Publications, Environment Agency R&D Dissemination Centre (2003). ## 29. میرمحمدی ن.، حمیدی ا.، "بررسی آزمایشگاهی رفتار ترمومکانیکی خاک‌های رسی اشباع دارای ساختار در دماهای بالا" پایان‌نامۀ کارشناسی ارشد، دانشکدۀ فنی مهندسی، دانشگاه خوارزمی (1394). ## 30. شرکت سیمان سفید بنوید، جدول مشخصات فیزیکی و شیمیایی سیمان سفید، بازیابی شده از آدرس http://www.benvid.com/index.aspx در اسفند (1394). ## 31. Merck Millipore, Phenol 100201, Retrieve from ## http://www.merckmillipore.com/ Access date: October 2015. ## 32. Barth E. F., Percin P. D., "Stabilization and Solidification of Hazardous Waste", Pollution Technology Review, NO. 186 (1990) 390. ## 33. U.S.EPA, "Stabilization/Solidification of CERCLA and RCRA Wastes, Physical Tests, Chemical Testing Procedure, Technology Screening, and Field Activities", Center for Environmental Research Information and Risk Reduction Engineering Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, Cincinnati, OH 45268, EPA/625/6-89/022 (1989). ## 34. Alibaba, Retrieve From https://www.alibaba.com/. Access date: (January 2016). ## 35. The Statistics Portal, Statista, Retrieve From http://www.made-in-china.com/. Access date: (January 2016). ##